Sterling Silver Jewelry in Lancaster County

Sterling Silver Jewelry in Lancaster County

Some of the best jewelry value in Lancaster County is sitting in our Sterling Silver case. At Maxwell & Co. Jewelry in Leola, our sterling collection is built around pre-owned designer and estate pieces — the names people drive to King of Prussia or order online to find — each one checked at our own bench, described honestly, and priced well under what the same piece costs new.

Designer sterling, without the boutique price

  • Real names, really here — Tiffany & Co., David Yurman, and Elsa Peretti's designs for Tiffany turn up in this collection regularly, alongside other fine sterling makers. When a piece carries a maker's mark, we read it, photograph it, and say exactly what it is.
  • Authenticated and honestly described — every piece is examined before it is listed: marks, stones, clasps, and condition. Wear is disclosed in the listing, never hidden, and nothing is called something it is not.
  • Estate prices, not retail prices — these are pre-owned pieces priced from what they actually bring, not from a boutique tag. The same names cost far more new; here they are priced to sell to the next person who will wear them.

Gifts that look like you spent more

Most of the Sterling Silver collection sits under $1,000 — fine jewelry gifts with real names on them, at prices that make sense for Christmas, birthdays, and anniversaries. Every piece is one of one: when it is gone, it is gone, and there is not another in the back. If you see the one, do not wait on it.

Selling sterling silver?

We buy sterling silver too — single pieces, sets, and full estates, evaluated in front of you at the store. See our gold, silver & coin buying page for how buying works, or just bring it in.

Start here

Browse the Sterling Silver collection — every piece is the exact piece pictured, and new pieces are added as they come out of the safe, so check back often (the footer newsletter is the first to know). Questions about a piece? Call or text (717) 475-8814, or visit 6 Glenbrook Rd, Leola, PA 17540 — Tuesday through Saturday, 10 AM to 5 PM (Saturday sometimes closes a little early).

Describe your repair! And we’ll get back to you as soon as possible!

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

  • ★★★★★ Britta Burton

    “It was a pleasure doing business with Nick. I had some gold and silver jewelry I no longer wanted. I went to 3 different places and he paid me the most. He was transparent and more than fair. I would recommend Maxwell to anyone looking to sell gold, silver or platinum. He also makes beautiful jewelry!”

  • ★★★★★ William Burke

    “I got a custom engagement ring made here and it was absolutely perfect. Made quickly but expertly and cheaper than competition. Dude is so personable and will work with you to make your dream piece of jewelery. The whole process was way smoother than I imagined it would be.”

  • ★★★★★ Shanna Deck

    “The owner Nick was amazing! I had three pieces of jewelry appraised. The turnaround time was one day and he beat the competition in pricing! Super happy with my experience definitely will go back. He DOES IT ALL! Great EXPERIENCE”

  • ★★★★★ Joey Weinhold

    “I called at 12pm to notify him I would be coming in later to have my wife's rings soldered together. We showed up around 2:15pm and dropped it off with our instructions. I live 18 minutes away and wasn't even home before he called me back and said it was completed. On top of the super fast turn around he did a flawless job! Would absolutely recommend to anyone looking for fast, fairly priced, and exceptional service.”

  • ★★★★★ Tristen Church

    “Maxwell is a very honest kind gentleman that I feel was fair with me on my gold trade in. I would recommend him to anyone looking to sell gold. He also had a nice selection of gold and silver pieces for sale.”

  • ★★★★★ Val Brackett

    “Maxwell and Co. Jewelry is my goto jeweler from this day forward! Nick is very knowledgeable, and his work is excellent! I had a wedding ring that needed repair. Wedding ring repaired same day at an affordable price! Nick spent an hour with me...customer service at its finest. Nick, keep up the great work! You have a customer for life!!”

  • ★★★★★ Sandy Lenahan

    “After reading so many great reviews we decided to bring my broken wedding/engagement ring to Nick to fix. Wow!!! We cannot say enough about how pleased we were with the results. All the reviews were right. Nick does fantastic work, is so pleasant to work with, and is honest and is better priced than others. We will definitely recommend you to others. Thank you so much for the superb job that you did with an old broken ring!!!”

  • ★★★★★ Melissa Byers

    “I broke my sterling silver chain that I wear every day with the charm from Ireland that means a lot to me... so I was in a pinch and my time was limited. I went in just an hour before they closed and Nicolas was very accommodating. Definitely knows his stuff plus very customer service oriented. I would recommend to anyone. Thank you, Nicolas.”

  • ★★★★★ Joel B

    “I've been carrying around an engagement ring from a previous relationship for a little bit now. After driving by Nicks shop a few times per week, I decided to reach out. Within minutes, I got a response via email. Nick made the experience of offloading the ring a positive one. He offered an extremely fair price and also filled me in on what the market on gold looks like today! If you're in the process of purchasing any sort of jewelry, I encourage you to skip the mainstream shops and support a small business like Maxwell And Co. Hand crafted jewelry, fair prices, 10/10 customer service! I'll be going back for any future purchases!”

1 of 9